Skip to the content

Many of you will have made employees redundant this year. You're obliged to consider ways of saving their jobs but does this duty extend to putting employees on your list of bank workers?

In Aramark (UK) Ltd v Fernandes, the Employment Appeal Tribunal ('EAT') said no.

When Aramark made Mr Fernandes redundant, it had a list of around 120 bank workers to cover staff absences. It didn't employ them nor was it obliged to provide them with work. However, the bank workers had a reasonable prospect of obtaining ad hoc work.

Mr Fernandez said that Aramark should have put him on the bank list because 'it offered him the chance of employment, which was better than no employment'.

Overturning the tribunal's decision that the dismissal was unfair, the EAT said that placing Mr Fernandes on the bank list would only have given him the prospect of work. It wouldn't have avoided his redundancy. Section 98(4) of the Employment Rights Act 1996 addressed 'the mischief of dismissal', but it didn't provide 'a statutory right to an alternative that might have had the potential to mitigate the adverse effects of dismissal'.

The dismissal was fair, but the case reminds us that:

  • Consulting affected employees on ways to avoid redundancies is crucial to ensure that any dismissal is fair.
  • You should make reasonable efforts to find suitable, alternative employment for redundant employees, but you're not required to go beyond what is reasonable.
  • You have a separate duty to offer any suitable alternative vacancy to an employee who is on maternity, adoption, or shared parental leave at the point of the redundancy.

Do speak to us if you need help with redundancies.

Employment law and HR update

Our annual update events were held in Manchester and London at the start of June and once again were a great success.  Thank you to all those who attended.

The essence of strategy is choosing what not to do.

Michael Porter

Contact Watershed

Telephone: +44 161 703 5611


Ryecroft, Aviary Road, Worsley, Manchester M28 2WF

Can we help?

If you want to find out more about our services, events or our employment law and HR expertise contact us  on +44 161 703 5611 and one of our dedicated advisers would be more than happy to help.